Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Rene Girard. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rene Girard. Show all posts

Monday, November 16, 2020

We All Need Somebody to Blame


 At first, Isabel Wilkerson's book, Caste, reminded me of Rene Girard's Scapegoat, but once Caste became personal, I fell under its spell.  Wilderson proves her point.  The USA has a caste system and black Americans are the lowest caste.  

Just about all the examples she gives, I remember.  I also remember my indifference to the events and the people involved in them--I am ashamed to say.  The most powerful chapter in the book is the last two chapters; she ends with a bang.  

"The Heart Is the Last Frontier," and the "Epilogue: A World Without Caste," meant the most to me.  I learned that regarding people as people gives one empathy for each other and that knocks down preconceptions.  Wilkerson waxes dreamily of a world without bias, where we enjoy everyone's talents and we are one people looking out for each other. (Didn't Jesus say that?)  

Personally, I think the solution is intermarriage.  If everyone has DNA from Asians, Africans, etc., and everyone has someone in their family who is gay or trans, etc., only then will everyone be free of prejudices.

But that's a reach, no?

However, I also remember from Girard's Scapegoat, that the human being needs to blame someone.  The most common question asked when anything happens is, "WHO did this?", not "How do we fix this?"  

Adam blamed Eve.  Eve blamed the serpent.  Who's going to get blamed next?

Saturday, April 4, 2020

Who Did This?

It has always annoyed me to no end, that most people ask the question: "Who did this?"  I've worked in many jobs in which the boss would FIRST ask, "Who did this?"  Pray tell, how does that solve the problem?  Knowing the name of the person who made the mistake, how does that solve the problem?  Punishing the person who erred, how does that solve the problem?

Why isn't the first question, "How do we fix this,"?  It looks like Rene Girard's scapegoating theory is correct.  People need someone to blame.  Girard posits that people need to blame somebody or something for happenstances that go wrong.  I'm sad to say I think he's correct.  Dictators are perfect examples of this.  Once the scapegoat is identified, the people have something to unite over--punish the scapegoat.

During this COVID-19 pandemic, I see this scapegoating, all the time, e.i., it's the president's fault, it's China's fault, it's the drug companies fault, it's hoarding, it's people not social distancing, etc..

STOP! Stop blaming and focus on the problem.



Rabbi

 Did you ever wonder why a simple carpenter was called Rabbi?  A rabbi is a teacher, a master in spiritual things.  And it wasn't just H...